0 reactions
Accused murderer Craig Rumsby tricked into confession, lawyer says
By Jacob Shteyman • AAP
3:50pm Jun 14, 2023
A man who admitted murdering teenager Michelle Bright more than 20 years ago did so falsely because he is unsophisticated and vulnerable to manipulation, a jury has heard.
Craig Rumsby, 56, confessed to undercover police he killed the 17-year-old because he was caught in a "ruse", his barrister Nicholas Broadbent told a NSW Supreme Court jury.
Broadbent argued his admissions could not be trusted because he was induced to give them by the prospect of financial and social reward.
READ MORE: Submarine that went missing on secret World War II mission found
Craig Rumsby, 56, confessed to undercover police he killed the 17-year-old because he was caught in a "ruse", his barrister Nicholas Broadbent told a NSW Supreme Court jury. (9News)
Parallel to the covert police operation, Rumsby was entangled in a romance scam, in which he believed he was in a relationship with an American woman who promised to come to Australia and buy the pair a house.
"This tells you a lot about Mr Rumsby," Broadbent said at Dubbo Courthouse on Wednesday.
"About his vulnerability to manipulation. His ability to accept the farfetched when he perceives a benefit. His unsophistication. His inability to consider risk versus reward."
Hair Transplant Treatment in Mexico Might Be Cheaper Than You Think SPONSORED | Search Ads
Recommended by
The jury heard Rumsby's vulnerability was heightened as he had little in the way of familial or social support and was struggling financially.
Rumsby is accused of murdering Bright after she left a friend's 15th birthday party in Gulgong , central west NSW in the early hours of February 27, 1999.
He is also charged with an assault on another 18-year-old woman after she left a New Year's Eve party on January 1, 1998.
He is alleged to have choked her with the intent of raping her.
He has pleaded not guilty to both charges.
Broadbent questioned the reliability of the alleged assault victim's evidence given to court , saying it differed from statements and photographic record taken on the day of her attack.
READ MORE: Katy Perry appeals trademark loss to Aussie designer
Rumsby is accused of murdering Bright after she left a friend's 15th birthday party in Gulgong, central west NSW in the early hours of February 27, 1999. (Supplied)
In the contemporaneous records, there is no mention of blood on the woman's face or that the assailant removed her underwear - evidence that she gave to the court over 20 years later.
The jury heard earlier in the trial the woman, who cannot be named, did not press charges against Rumsby and retracted a statement she made at the time as she feared going to court and having her character discredited.
Crown prosecutor Lee Carr SC on Tuesday argued Rumsby's admissions to undercover police prove his guilt in both offences beyond reasonable doubt.
"The accused had a particular state of mind, that being a sexual interest in females, including strangers, in their late teens," he said.
"He had a tendency to act on that state of mind by committing sexual violence on them opportunistically."
The similarity of both offences - in terms of the time, location and manner of the attacks - would make it "extraordinary in the extreme" if they were by sheer coincidence committed by different assailants, he said.
The trial continues.
Sign up here to receive our daily newsletters and breaking news alerts, sent straight to your inbox.
Courts National Australia Crime Police New South Wales
CONTACT US
Send your photos, videos and stories to 9News [email protected]
Auto news: 2022 Maserati SUV lineup due by the end of the year - drive.com.au
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
Recommended by
1/5
Chirop ractic Treatment Cost in Mexico:
Might Cheaper Than You Think.
SPONSORED | Search Ads
2023s latest German hearing aid technology is now available in India. Try for yourself
SPON SORED |
Hea r.com
Mig raine Treatment Cost in Mexico Might Be Cheaper Than You Think
SP ONSORED | Search Ads
On e Bedroom Apartments For Seniors In Ahmedabad That Might Surprise You
S PONSORED | Apartments For Seniors | Sponsored
B ack Pain Treatment Cost in Mexico Might Be Cheaper Than You
SPONSORED | Back Pain - Sponsored Links
Electric Cars in Ahmedabad , the price might surprise you SPONSORED | Search Ads
TOP STORIES
Tributes for bus crash victims as families mourn
IN PICTURES
Spirit of the Bush photograph winners announced
'Congestion tax' for Sydney CBD commuters ruled out
Lidia Thorpe accuses Liberal senator of sexual assault, harassment12 minutes ago
About
Contact
Watch TV
News
Sport
Lifestyle
Entertainment
Product Reviews
Radio
Stan
Domain
Drive
Pedestrian TV
Coupons
Home
Newsletters
Careers
Advertise with us
Support
Terms of use
Privacy
© 2023 Nine Entertainment Co.
| 0 mlx | |
| 39 | |
| 0 |