Why aren't more Africans pushing back against governments…
0 reactions
Why aren't more Africans pushing back against governments that are obviously lying to us?
**TLDR: To fix crises, you first need to acknowledge them but fake statistics prevent us doing so.**
If you look at African countries purely from the lens of govt-reported stats, they look like absolute rock stars. But the lived reality of most people is different from what the numbers say. So why do we as African citizens just... accept the narrative? Is it easier to believe the numbers than sit with the weight of what they’re hiding?
Peer economies like Benin, Burundi and Nigeria. Yes, Africa’s most populous nation and supposed giant. All reporting unemployment in the low single digits. How? Because these governments aren’t measuring prosperity. They’re counting anyone who hawked phone credit or carried bags at a motor park last week as “employed” and calling it a win. And we nod along, because the alternative, acknowledging that most of us are scrambling not thriving, is harder to stomach.
And the headline numbers don’t survive scrutiny. Nigeria’s economy collapsed from $574 billion to $188 billion in a decade. Not because activity vanished, but because a naira that had been artificially propped up for years finally met reality. Per capita income halved. The AfDB president observed that Nigerians are now worse off than at independence. Yet the central bank still burned through $7.5 billion in 2025 alone trying to resist the market’s verdict on the currency. When even that wasn’t enough to save face? The statistics bureau rebased the GDP, announcing it would now count “illegal and hidden activities” including drug trafficking and prostitution. This, in a country whose own data shows a kidnapping-for-ransom industry generating trillions of naira annually. If this is what success looks like on paper, why aren’t we asking what failure looks like?
Abuja vs the rest of Nigeria. Addis vs rural Ethiopia. Accra vs northern Ghana. The pattern repeats everywhere. One city gets the new roads, the convention centers, the clean streets. Gets held up at Davos as proof the model works. We share the photos. We beam with pride. But step outside the capital and the picture changes fast. Pour resources into one city, point cameras at it, call it transformation. Meanwhile the majority of the population lives somewhere the investment never reaches. Why do we celebrate the showroom and ignore the warehouse? Is it because the gleaming capital lets us feel like we’re part of something that’s working, even when we know deep down that most of us aren’t?
When 40% of Rwanda’s budget comes from foreign donors and the country is borrowing heavy on top of that, that’s not a sovereign economy. It’s a sponsored one. Rwanda is basically running on other people’s money while betting that future returns will justify today’s spending. But development economics is littered with countries that made that exact same bet and lost. If the aid dries up or the debt comes due before self-sustaining growth kicks in, the whole thing collapses. Yet we hold it up as a model. Why? Because it’s comforting to believe that somewhere on the continent, someone has figured it out?
The uncomfortable truth might be that the “Africa rising” narrative serves everyone except ordinary Africans. It serves donor governments justifying aid budgets. Autocrats seeking legitimacy. International investors hunting for frontier markets. But maybe it serves us too in a way. It gives us a story we can live with. It lets us point to a GDP figure or a skyline and say we’re getting there, without confronting the fact that for most people on this continent “there” keeps moving further away.
At some point we have to ask ourselves. Are we accepting these narratives because we believe them? Or because the truth is just too painful to sit with?
I know the instinctive rebuttal is "yeah but others are doing it", but you don't we're not lemmings and shouldn't act as though we are.
Sauces:
Benin unemployment rate (1.4%): https://tradingeconomics.com/benin/unemployment-rate
Burundi unemployment rate (\~0.9%): https://tradingeconomics.com/burundi/unemployment-rate
Nigeria unemployment rate (4%) and methodology criticism: https://punchng.com/nigerias-unemployment-rate-hits-0-8-in-2023-q3-nbs-report/
Inflating GDP with illicit activities (editorial): https://businessday.ng/editorial/article/nigerias-economic-mirage-inflating-gdp-with-illicit-activities/
NBS Crime Survey: ₦2.2 trillion in ransom payments: https://www.thecable.ng/questioning-the-numbers-a-fresh-look-at-nbs-data-on-kidnapping-ransom-payment/
Kidnapping as a self-sustaining business model: https://businessday.ng/news/article/kidnap-for-ransom-industry-costs-nigeria-n2-56bn-in-one-year-report/
Rwanda: over 40% of national budget funded by foreign aid: https://issafrica.org/iss-today/could-fdi-be-rwandas-lifeline-as-donors-pull-the-plug
Rwanda revised budget, declining aid and rising loans: https://rwandadispatch.com/rwandas-parliament-approves-revised-budget-for-2024-2025/
Disclosure: I really dislike the "Africa Rising" narrative because it's condescending
#local
**TLDR: To fix crises, you first need to acknowledge them but fake statistics prevent us doing so.**
If you look at African countries purely from the lens of govt-reported stats, they look like absolute rock stars. But the lived reality of most people is different from what the numbers say. So why do we as African citizens just... accept the narrative? Is it easier to believe the numbers than sit with the weight of what they’re hiding?
Peer economies like Benin, Burundi and Nigeria. Yes, Africa’s most populous nation and supposed giant. All reporting unemployment in the low single digits. How? Because these governments aren’t measuring prosperity. They’re counting anyone who hawked phone credit or carried bags at a motor park last week as “employed” and calling it a win. And we nod along, because the alternative, acknowledging that most of us are scrambling not thriving, is harder to stomach.
And the headline numbers don’t survive scrutiny. Nigeria’s economy collapsed from $574 billion to $188 billion in a decade. Not because activity vanished, but because a naira that had been artificially propped up for years finally met reality. Per capita income halved. The AfDB president observed that Nigerians are now worse off than at independence. Yet the central bank still burned through $7.5 billion in 2025 alone trying to resist the market’s verdict on the currency. When even that wasn’t enough to save face? The statistics bureau rebased the GDP, announcing it would now count “illegal and hidden activities” including drug trafficking and prostitution. This, in a country whose own data shows a kidnapping-for-ransom industry generating trillions of naira annually. If this is what success looks like on paper, why aren’t we asking what failure looks like?
Abuja vs the rest of Nigeria. Addis vs rural Ethiopia. Accra vs northern Ghana. The pattern repeats everywhere. One city gets the new roads, the convention centers, the clean streets. Gets held up at Davos as proof the model works. We share the photos. We beam with pride. But step outside the capital and the picture changes fast. Pour resources into one city, point cameras at it, call it transformation. Meanwhile the majority of the population lives somewhere the investment never reaches. Why do we celebrate the showroom and ignore the warehouse? Is it because the gleaming capital lets us feel like we’re part of something that’s working, even when we know deep down that most of us aren’t?
When 40% of Rwanda’s budget comes from foreign donors and the country is borrowing heavy on top of that, that’s not a sovereign economy. It’s a sponsored one. Rwanda is basically running on other people’s money while betting that future returns will justify today’s spending. But development economics is littered with countries that made that exact same bet and lost. If the aid dries up or the debt comes due before self-sustaining growth kicks in, the whole thing collapses. Yet we hold it up as a model. Why? Because it’s comforting to believe that somewhere on the continent, someone has figured it out?
The uncomfortable truth might be that the “Africa rising” narrative serves everyone except ordinary Africans. It serves donor governments justifying aid budgets. Autocrats seeking legitimacy. International investors hunting for frontier markets. But maybe it serves us too in a way. It gives us a story we can live with. It lets us point to a GDP figure or a skyline and say we’re getting there, without confronting the fact that for most people on this continent “there” keeps moving further away.
At some point we have to ask ourselves. Are we accepting these narratives because we believe them? Or because the truth is just too painful to sit with?
I know the instinctive rebuttal is "yeah but others are doing it", but you don't we're not lemmings and shouldn't act as though we are.
Sauces:
Benin unemployment rate (1.4%): https://tradingeconomics.com/benin/unemployment-rate
Burundi unemployment rate (\~0.9%): https://tradingeconomics.com/burundi/unemployment-rate
Nigeria unemployment rate (4%) and methodology criticism: https://punchng.com/nigerias-unemployment-rate-hits-0-8-in-2023-q3-nbs-report/
Inflating GDP with illicit activities (editorial): https://businessday.ng/editorial/article/nigerias-economic-mirage-inflating-gdp-with-illicit-activities/
NBS Crime Survey: ₦2.2 trillion in ransom payments: https://www.thecable.ng/questioning-the-numbers-a-fresh-look-at-nbs-data-on-kidnapping-ransom-payment/
Kidnapping as a self-sustaining business model: https://businessday.ng/news/article/kidnap-for-ransom-industry-costs-nigeria-n2-56bn-in-one-year-report/
Rwanda: over 40% of national budget funded by foreign aid: https://issafrica.org/iss-today/could-fdi-be-rwandas-lifeline-as-donors-pull-the-plug
Rwanda revised budget, declining aid and rising loans: https://rwandadispatch.com/rwandas-parliament-approves-revised-budget-for-2024-2025/
Disclosure: I really dislike the "Africa Rising" narrative because it's condescending
#local
| 3,000 mlx | |
| 4 | |
| 0 |