Suggestions for a family Caribbean trip in July, but must have fishing options
Planning our family trip to include 6 adults (3 couples + 1 teenager) for end of July
Criteria:
* <5 hour non-stop flight from Washington DC * avoiding places already traveled (MX, Cayman, DR, PR, Aruba, Bahamas, ST Martin, Barbados, Jamaica) * 4-bedroom accommodations * private chef (if not in a resort) * private pool * beachfront * kayaks and other non-motorized/motorized activities * fishing that is within walking distance or a short golf-cart drive away (not really looking for deep sea excursions) * around $6,000/night
This really seems to leave the only destinations to be Turks & Caicos, St. Thomas, and Panama.
My father (who has the fishing requirement) recently came back from Guana Island and loved it, but is preferring a direct flight for this trip.. Unless I can find a similar private island spot that is easily accessible and fits the above criteria, he may be persuaded.
My mother is the one who has the remaining criteria so it's making it very difficult to find an option that also has nearby fishing.